Text Size:
A a |
A a |
A a
Sports Drinks Vs. Water
by Mitzi Dulan, RD | February 25, 2009
Confused about whether you should choose water or a sports drink to replace your lost fluids during exercise? Well, you are not alone. You have probably been bombarded by all of the advertisements and product claims by sports drinks. Let's start out by answering the question...what is a sports drink? Sports drinks are a combination of water, carbohydrates, and electrolytes (e.g. sodium and potassium). Not only do sports drinks provide the necessary fluids an active person needs but they can also help maintain stamina in events or exercise sessions lasting longer than 60 minutes. This is done by providing a small amount of carbohydrate to the working muscles. Sports drinks actually enhance fluid absorption in the small intestine due to the glucose and sodium content. Therefore, sport drinks can have a positive effect on performance and are recommended for events or exercise sessions lasting longer than one hour.
However, if you are not exercising for at least one hour then you do not need a sports drink and water is the best source of fluid for you. Best of all, water is free and it will adequately replace any lost fluids for the average person exercising less than one hour! However, if you do not like water and will not drink it after exercise then you would be better off drinking a sports drink for the simple fact of fulfilling fluid replacement needs. Many people do find that the better the liquid tastes the more they can drink and research has proven this point.
Some commonly asked questions about sports drinks and fluid needs:
-
How do I pick out the best sports drink for me?
Choose a sports drink that is 5-8% carbohydrates or 50-80 calories per 8 oz with 120-170 mg sodium. Beverages with higher carbohydrate content (e.g. sodas, orange juice) are too concentrated and delay absorption. As you evaluate different sports drinks you should look for a sports drink that replaces body water losses, provides fuel if necessary, tastes good, and does not give you any GI discomfort.
- How much do fluid needs change for someone who exercises regularly?
Good question, the common recommendation for 8 glasses of water a day
is for sedentary individuals. Hopefully, you are not sedentary so you
will need approximately 10-12 glasses of water per day including the
following fluid recommendations for exercise. Drink 1-2 cups 2 hours
prior to exercise Drink 1-2 cups 15-20 minutes before exercise Drink
1/2-1 cup every 15 minutes during exercise (this is the best time to
benefit from a sports drink) *Replace each pound of weight loss with 2
cups of water or sports drink following exercise.
- How do I know if I am drinking enough fluid during the day?
First
of all you want your urine to be clear and pale yellow. This can vary
depending on use of supplements and medications. Secondly, if you are
thirsty, then you are already dehydrated so don't use thirst as an
indicator for fluid needs. Drink regularly throughout the entire day.
Some signs to look for if you think you might be dehydrated include
fatigue, dark urine, headaches, loss of appetite, flushed skin, and
light-headedness. So, do not wait until you are thirsty to drink!
- Does it matter what kind of carbohydrate the sports drink contains?
Yes, glucose and sucrose have been found to improve performance.
But fructose has been known to cause cramps, stomachache, diarrhea, and
bloating in some people that have a "fructose intolerance".
- Do you have any sports drink recipes for those of us on a budget?
Yes, below is a good recipe. Drink up! 8 oz ice water or caffeine-free
lemon tea 1 tablespoon sugar Pinch of salt (1/16 teaspoon) 1 ounce
orange juice or 2 tablespoons lemon juice. Dissolve the sugar and salt
in the hot tea or a little hot water. Add juice and remaining ice water
or tea. Drink cold for best taste.
Serves 1.
Fluid Replacement Beverages
Beverage
(Per 8 oz serving)
|
Calories
|
Carbs
(CHO gms)
|
CHO %
|
Sodium
(mg)
|
Potassium
(mg) |
Carbohydrate Ingredient
|
Gatorade®
Gatorade Company
|
50 |
14
|
6
|
110
|
30
|
Sucrose,glucose,
fructose
|
| Powerade® Coca-Cola |
70
|
19
|
8
|
55
|
30
|
High fructose corn syrup,
glucose polymers
|
AllSport®
Pepsico |
70
|
19
|
8
|
55
|
55
|
High fructose corn syrup
|
HydraFuel®
Twinlabs |
66
|
16
|
7 |
25
|
50
|
Glucose polymers, glucose, fructose
|
| Cytomax® Champion Nutrition |
66
|
13
|
5
|
53
|
100
|
Corn starch, fructose, glucose
|
| Exceed® Weider Health & Fitness |
70
|
17
|
7
|
50
|
45
|
Glucose polymers, fructose
|
10-K® Suntory Water Group, Inc.
|
60
|
15
|
6
|
55
|
30
|
Sucrose, Fructose
|
Quickick® Quick Kick
|
67
|
16
|
7
|
100
|
23
|
High fructose corn syrup
|
1st Ade® American Beverages
|
60
|
16
|
7
|
55
|
25
|
High fructose corn syrup, glucose, sucrose, fructose
|
Coca-Cola®
|
103
|
27
|
11
|
6
|
0
|
High fructose corn syrup, sucrose
|
Orange Juice
|
104
|
25
|
10
|
6
|
436
|
Fructose, sucrose, glucose
|
Water
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
Low
|
Low
|
None |
 |
| advertisement |
|
|
 |
| advertisement |
 |
| advertisement |
|